Texas CPS Agrees to Pay $127K Sanction for Wrongful Removal of Children – But Does Not Admit to Doing Anything Wrong

Massachusetts Human Trafficking
Texas Bright Family

Bright family. Photo: Michael Ciaglo, Houston Chronicle

by Mike Hixenbaugh and Keri Blakinger
Houston Chronicle


Six months after a Harris County judge hit Child Protective Services with a rare $127,000 sanction for wrongfully removing a Tomball couple’s children, the state agency has abandoned its appeal and agreed to pay what may be an unprecedented sum for its handling of the case.

But the agency still hasn’t admitted wrongdoing, a fact that irked the family and their attorneys.

“To this day, they just can’t admit that they screwed up — to me that’s the saddest part for all of the children in Harris County,” said Stephanie Proffitt, one of the attorneys representing Melissa and Dillon Bright.

“They could have at least said we may have messed this one up and we’ll do better next time. Instead they’re basically taking no responsibility. Shame on them.”

It’s not clear what prompted the agency to drop the appeal, though in a statement a spokesman cited the need to focus resources on other local children.

Had the court of appeals ruled against them it could have set a precedent that would make it easier for other families to win sanctions in similar cases.

The Bright case drew statewide attention and raised concerns about the process CPS follows after receiving a report of abuse from a child abuse pediatrician, a small but growing medical subspecialty.

The doctors are based at major children’s hospitals across the nation and work closely with child welfare agents and law enforcement officials in cases of suspected abuse.

Read the full story at the Houston Chronicle.

See Also:

Texas Judge Sanctions CPS $127K for Wrongfully Taking Couple’s Children and Lying to the Court

New Proposed Texas Bill would Stop Child Protective Services from Falsifying Records

The post Texas CPS Agrees to Pay $127K Sanction for Wrongful Removal of Children – But Does Not Admit to Doing Anything Wrong appeared first on Massachusetts Trafficking Humans.

Massachusetts Human Trafficking
Paternity Fraud ‘Can be Devastating for Men’

August 9, 2019 by Robert Franklin, Esq. Few publications I’ve read deal adequately with the issue of paternity fraud, but this piece is an exception (VeryWell, 7/12/19).  It’s an accurate and informative article that men, particularly young men, should familiarize themselves with. Paternity fraud occurs when a man is led Read More

Massachusetts Human Trafficking
The Weaponizing of CPS – Lose Your Children IF: You Don’t Vaccinate, You Don’t Make a Dentist Appointment, You Don’t Pay School Lunch Fees, You Don’t Shut Up, Etc.

In a military SWAT-like operation Arizona police break down the door of a family at 1 AM because the parents did not take one of their children who had a fever to an emergency room at the request of a doctor. The child was reportedly sleeping soundly and only had Read More

Massachusetts Human Trafficking
The Criminal Justice System Has Failed to Reduce Domestic Violence

August 2, 2019 by Robert Franklin, Esq. A criminal justice approach to domestic violence hasn’t ameliorated the problem and may be making it worse. We need to find other methods of addressing DV if we’re to reduce its incidence. That’s the gist of this much-needed article by Professor Leigh Goodmark Read More